Who wouldn't want a hurricane-proofed home? Especially when your abode is within the hurricane prone vicinity. Nobody wants to see their hard earned shelter shatter into logs or like morsels everytime a feisty disaster strikes. That is why, In 2003, Geraldine and Tony Luppino built a home on a thumb of land that juts into St. Helena Sound. Fearing hurricanes, they made sure their new house was solid, complete with foot-thick concrete walls, hurricane straps for the roof and impact-resistant windows. In all, they paid a contractor $583,435.


But after a year or two - “We couldn’t believe it,” Geraldine said. “It was almost a million dollars more than we paid to build it, and it had nothing to do with our personal belongings. It was for the building only. It didn’t make sense.” - that was when they got a letter from Nationwide, their insurance carrier. The insurer had a new calculation for the home’s “replacement cost” — $1.54 million. Their premium and deductible would be based on this new figure.

Stories like these are fueling a push to change an insurance playing field that critics say is tilted against consumers. On March 21, state Sen. Tom Davis, R-Beaufort, filed what he called the “Competitive Insurance Act,” legislation he said he hopes will help lure more companies to South Carolina and lower rates.


Read more of these frustrated retirees' story. Go to www.postandcourier.com